Ahem. Anyways, another issue is that most activity books, especially involving outdoor, building, or potentially "risky" activities are directed towards boys, either openly or implicitly while more "craft" type books tend to be directed towards girls.
This book, although it does have some flaws, creates a female-friendly space for girls to try a wide range of activities, from camping to cooking, without judgment or commentary on their preferences. Each chapter includes a wide range of activities from general suggestions to step-by-step projects, as well as information and some reflections on different ways to experience and try the subject. Readers can explore science, the outdoors, sports, art and literature, building, and cooking. Badges and further reading for more activities are included in the back.
The main criticisms leveled at the book are that some of the activities are not clearly explained or diagrammed and some disregard some basic safety components, like building a campfire. I have mixed feelings as to whether those are problems or not; on the one hand, girls with no prior experience and no guiding adult may find themselves frustrated or in trouble. On the other hand, one of the real barriers to kids getting active and experimenting is how heavily scheduled and surrounded by rules and instructions they are. It's a constant frustration to me that when I try to do art projects or hands-on activities with the kids I frequently get a recurrent chorus of "but what are we supposed to DO?" followed by "it's not working right!" The way to learn is to do, to explore is to experience, and a little risk along the way is, to my mind, a good thing.
Verdict: If you have a lot of bored kids around or, conversely, a lot of active kids who like to try different things, this book just might click with some of them. However, if your audience have their lives tidily organized from dawn to dusk by adults or at the other end of the spectrum completely lacks any resources or adult presence, this may be better used as a professional resource to help build experiential programs.
ISBN: 9781524861179; Published May 2021 by Andrews McMeel; Review copy provided by the publisher and donated to the library
No comments:
Post a Comment